This week I was listening to Morgan Housel, and one comment caught my attention. He said that the demand for forecasts and predictions is highest precisely when they are least useful. He was speaking about financial markets, but I found myself thinking about leadership, and perhaps life more generally.
When things are relatively stable, we do not spend much time obsessing over the future. We make plans, execute them, and make adjustments along the way. But when things become uncertain, our appetite for certainty seems to increase dramatically. We want forecasts, answers and reassurance. We want someone to tell us exactly what happens next. The Irony, of course, is that uncertainty is usually highest when the number of variables is exploding around us.
This isn’t just an investing lesson and it is not a new problem. Military strategists have been wrestling with it for centuries. There is a famous saying that no plan survives first contact with the enemy. I have always found that idea fascinating, not because it suggests planning is pointless, but quite the opposite.
Military organisations plan extensively. They run scenarios, model outcomes, and prepare contingencies. They recognise something many of us forget. The purpose of planning is not to predict the future perfectly. The purpose of planning is to prepare people to respond when reality turns out differently than expected.
The same seems true in business. Over the past few years, we have all experienced some version of this through pandemics, geopolitical tensions, supply chain disruptions, inflation and rapid advances in technology and AI. The environment is changing faster than many planning cycles can keep up. Yet our response is often to ask for even more certainty. What will happen next quarter? What will customers do? What will competitors do? What will the market do?
Perhaps that is the wrong question. The future will always contain too many unknowns to forecast with confidence. A more useful question might be: how quickly can we respond when reality surprises us?
Psychology offers an interesting explanation for why this is so difficult. Humans are wired to seek certainty. Research consistently shows that uncertainty creates stress and discomfort. In many cases, people prefer a bad outcome they can predict over uncertainty about what comes next. As leaders, we often feel pressure to provide certainty because uncertainty makes people uncomfortable. The temptation is to act as though we know more than we do.
But increasingly, I wonder whether the most effective leaders are not the ones who create certainty where none exists. Perhaps they are the ones who create confidence without pretending certainty exists. They communicate clearly about what is known, what is not known, what they are watching and how they will respond as they learn more.
Some of the best leaders I have worked with were not the people who made the most accurate predictions. They were the people who adjusted fastest when reality turned out differently from what everyone expected. They built teams that learned quickly, encouraged information to flow freely and were willing to change their minds when new facts emerged.
Interestingly, investing seems to reward the same behaviour. Long-term investors rarely succeed because they correctly predict every market movement. They succeed because they stay in the game. They avoid catastrophic mistakes, continue learning, adapt when circumstances change and allow good decisions to compound over time.
The same principle applies to leadership. Most leaders already know that forecasts are imperfect and that adaptability matters. The real challenge is whether organisations are structured to learn and respond quickly when conditions change. Because in a world where certainty is increasingly scarce, our ability to respond may matter more than our ability to predict.
I am still thinking about this, and it has left me wondering whether we spend too much time asking leaders to predict the future and not enough time asking them to build organisations capable of adapting to it.

Leave a Reply